wandering...
top of page

Want me to plan your Hudson trip?

This post may contain affiliate links. If you book or buy through them, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

10 Cozy Hudson Valley Restaurants with Real Fireplaces for Winter

Writer: Ryan Jones
Ryan Jones
22 minutes ago
7 min read

When it's the coldest night of the year, I want a real fireplace, a heavy menu, and a room that's been doing this for a couple of centuries. The Hudson Valley is full of those rooms. Some of these restaurants are in buildings older than the country, and almost all of them light the fire once the cold sets in.


I started with the restaurants from my video and built it out to a full list of ten. Every place below is open as of November 2026, and I checked the fireplace, history, and menu details against each restaurant's own website and recent regional coverage. Menus change with the seasons, so treat my "what to order" as a starting point.


Planning a whole trip around it? Read my winter weekend in the Hudson Valley guide next.



The List at a Glance


Restaurant

Town

Order This

The Hoffman House

Kingston

French onion soup and a steak

The Tavern at the Beekman Arms

Rhinebeck

Chicken pot pie

The Bird & Bottle Inn

Garrison

Braised short rib

The Old '76 House

Tappan

The '76 pork chop with apple-brandy glaze

Stissing House

Pine Plains

Wood-roasted chicken

Wm. Farmer and Sons

Hudson

A classic cocktail by the fire

Old Drovers Inn

Dover Plains

Dinner in the Tap Room

The Inn at Pound Ridge by Jean-Georges

Pound Ridge

Wine and a pizza by the fire

Casa Susanna

Leeds

Shared plates with house-made tortillas

Edwards Tavern at Little Cat Lodge

Hillsdale

Pork schnitzel after skiing Catamount



Historic Taverns with Fireplaces


1. The Hoffman House — Kingston


A crock of French onion soup topped with melted, browned cheese

The Hoffman House is a Dutch Colonial stone house in uptown Kingston's historic Stockade district, and it's listed on the National Register of Historic Places. It has been a restaurant since 1977. The house has four dining rooms, and three of them have big stone fireplaces, so you have a good chance of eating near one.


What to order: The French onion soup, which the restaurant says is one of its most popular dishes all year, then a steak.


Good to know: It's at 94 N. Front Street and is open for lunch and dinner Tuesday through Saturday, closed Sunday and Monday. You can book on OpenTable.



2. The Tavern at the Beekman Arms — Rhinebeck


A plated dinner at the Tavern at the Beekman Arms in Rhinebeck

Photo courtesy of the Beekman Arms & Delamater Inn


The Beekman Arms has operated in the center of Rhinebeck since 1766 and calls itself America's oldest operating inn. The Tavern's Colonial Tap Room is the room you want: low overhead beams, a charming bar, and an open-hearth fireplace.


What to order: The chicken pot pie, which reviewers keep coming back for.


Good to know: The Tavern serves lunch and dinner every day, with brunch on Sunday. Book through the Resy link on the Beekman Arms website or call the Tavern at (845) 876-1766.



3. The Bird & Bottle Inn — Garrison


Green walls, framed paintings, and booth seating at the Bird and Bottle Inn

Photo courtesy of The Bird & Bottle Inn


The Bird & Bottle has been welcoming travelers since 1761, back when it was a stop on the old Albany Post Road. It reopened in 2022 after a careful restoration, and the main dining room is built around a central fireplace, with olive green booths and walls of old paintings. There's also a five-room inn if you'd rather not drive home.


What to order: The menu is seasonal. Right now it has a braised boneless short rib with heirloom grits and red wine demi-glace. Duck pappardelle has appeared on past menus, so check whether it's back.


Good to know: Dinner runs Wednesday through Friday from 4:30 to 10 p.m., Saturday from noon to 10 p.m., and Sunday from 4:30 to 9 p.m., with Sunday brunch from 11 a.m. to 3 p.m. They also run a weeknight three-course prix fixe on Wednesday, Thursday, and Sunday.



4. The Old '76 House — Tappan


A fireplace in the historic dining room at the Old '76 House in Tappan, New York

Photo courtesy of The Old '76 House


The '76 House calls itself America's oldest restaurant. The owners date it to 1668, though historians debate the exact year. What isn't debated is the history: during the Revolution, British Major John André was held here after his capture in 1780. Today it's on the National Register of Historic Places, with low timber beams and four fireplaces.


What to order: The '76 Famous Pork Chop, a double-cut Berkshire chop with a Hudson Valley apple-brandy glaze. The Onion Soup Lafayette is another house classic.


Good to know: It's at 110 Main Street in Tappan, about 40 minutes from Manhattan. It serves lunch and dinner daily and a Sunday brunch buffet. Reservations are by phone at (845) 359-5476.




Farm-to-Table by the Fire


5. Stissing House — Pine Plains


The candlelit dining room and bar at Stissing House in Pine Plains

Photo courtesy of Stissing House


Stissing House was built in 1782 as the tavern for Pine Plains, with rooms for travelers and a domed ballroom. Since 2022 it's been run by chef Clare de Boer, a 2018 Food & Wine Best New Chef, and the kitchen cooks over a wood fire. The parlor is the coziest room, centered on an open fireplace.


What to order: The wood-roasted chicken with potatoes and cress, which has been a favorite since she opened.


Good to know: It's at 7801 South Main Street. Book through the restaurant's website, and book early, because weekend tables go fast.



6. Wm. Farmer and Sons — Hudson


The exposed brick barroom at Wm. Farmer and Sons in Hudson, New York

Photo courtesy of Wm. Farmer and Sons


Wm. Farmer and Sons is a barroom, restaurant, and small inn in an 1830s brick building on Front Street, a short walk from the Hudson Amtrak station. The barroom has a central fireplace and exposed brick, and the menu is seasonal American food from local farms.


What to order: A classic cocktail by the fire, then whatever is seasonal on the dinner menu.


Good to know: It's at 20 S. Front Street and serves dinner Monday, Tuesday, and Thursday through Saturday. Book on Resy. Some of the rooms upstairs have their own fireplaces.



7. Old Drovers Inn — Dover Plains


The bar in the Tap Room at Old Drovers Inn in Dover Plains, New York

Photo courtesy of Old Drovers Inn


Old Drovers Inn dates to 1750 and once served the cattle drovers who drove herds down the post roads to New York City markets. Dinner is served in the Tap Room, and there's an open fire in the parlor where you can settle in before or after your meal.


What to order: The classic tavern menu in the Tap Room. Come on a Wednesday for the more casual pub night.


Good to know: It's at 196 E. Duncan Hill Road. Pub night is Wednesday from 4 to 9 p.m., and dinner is Thursday through Saturday from 5 to 9 p.m. Reservations are preferred.



8. The Inn at Pound Ridge by Jean-Georges — Pound Ridge


The beamed dining room at the Inn at Pound Ridge by Jean-Georges

Photo courtesy of The Inn at Pound Ridge by Jean-Georges


This one is in northern Westchester, one of the closest stops on the list for a lot of people coming from the city or New Jersey. The building went up in 1833 as a home and later became an inn, and the renovation kept four working fireplaces. It's Jean-Georges Vongerichten's restaurant, with seasonal, farm-to-table cooking.


What to order: A glass of wine and a pizza by the fire is the move the restaurant itself suggests. Go for the full dinner if it's a special occasion.


Good to know: It's at 258 Westchester Avenue and books on OpenTable. Ask for a table near one of the fireplaces when you reserve.



Newer Favorites Worth the Drive


9. Casa Susanna — Leeds


The log cabin style dining room at Casa Susanna in Leeds, New York

Photo courtesy of Camptown


Casa Susanna is the restaurant at the Camptown hotel in Leeds, just outside Catskill. Chef Efrén Hernández cooks modern Mexican food from his family's traditions and Hudson Valley ingredients, with house-made tortillas and plates meant for sharing. The room is a 1970s-style log cabin with a stone fireplace and a small lounge where you can have a drink by the fire while you wait.


What to order: A spread of shared plates. The menu changes often, so ask what's new.


Good to know: Dinner is Thursday through Tuesday from 5 to 10 p.m. (closed Wednesday), with brunch on Saturday and Sunday. Book on Resy.



10. Edwards Tavern at Little Cat Lodge — Hillsdale


The warm wood interior of Edwards Tavern at Little Cat Lodge in Hillsdale

Photo courtesy of Little Cat Lodge


Little Cat Lodge is a renovated, European ski-chalet-style lodge on Catamount Road, right by the Catamount ski area. Its restaurant, Edwards Tavern, has a wood-burning fireplace and cozy booths, which makes it the best après-ski stop on this list.


What to order: The pork schnitzel or the steak frites after a day on the mountain.


Good to know: It's at 37 Catamount Road. Dinner is Thursday through Sunday from 4 to 9 p.m., with brunch Saturday and Sunday from 11 a.m. to 3 p.m. Book on Resy.




Tips for Getting a Table by the Fire


  • Ask for it when you book. Most of these restaurants can't promise a fireplace table, but asking early gives you the best chance.

  • Go early or go midweek. Weekend prime time fills first, especially once it snows.

  • Check the days. Several of these are closed early in the week, and some close for short winter breaks.

  • Stay over. The Bird & Bottle, Wm. Farmer and Sons, Old Drovers Inn, and Little Cat Lodge all have rooms, so you don't have to drive home on icy roads.


Want more cold-weather ideas? See my cozy winter getaways within 3 hours of New Jersey.



Frequently Asked Questions


The Old '76 House in Tappan calls itself America's oldest restaurant and dates itself to 1668, though the exact year is debated. The Bird & Bottle Inn (1761), the Beekman Arms (1766), and Stissing House (1782) are also older than the country.

All ten on this list do, including the Hoffman House in Kingston, the Tavern at the Beekman Arms in Rhinebeck, the Bird & Bottle Inn in Garrison, and Stissing House in Pine Plains.

Usually you can only request one. Ask when you book and again when you arrive.

The Bird & Bottle Inn, the Beekman Arms, Wm. Farmer and Sons, Old Drovers Inn, Little Cat Lodge, and Camptown (home of Casa Susanna) all have rooms.




Comments


bottom of page