The Best September Getaways in New Jersey: Your Guide to Local Summer & Fall Beach Trips in NJ
- Ryan Jones
- Aug 18
- 5 min read
September is when New Jersey’s shore towns exhale—warm ocean, softer rates, and boardwalks that feel local again. If you love the energy of summer minus the lines, this “local summer New Jersey” window is your sweet spot. Ocean temps stay swimmable, nights turn just cool enough for a light layer, and restaurants are far easier to book. You can blend beach time with early fall events, lighthouse climbs, wine tastings, or a lazy stroll through historic districts. Below are the best September getaways New Jersey has to offer—Asbury Park, Cape May, and Long Beach Island—each with what to do, where to eat, and fall beach trips NJ stays that fit the vibe.
Why September Is the Best Time to Go
Lower crowds, warmer water, and a calmer pace let you actually hear the waves and enjoy sunset cocktails without a wait. Local summer means easier parking, more personal service, and a chance to upgrade rooms without peak-season pricing. It’s also festival season: chowder competitions, Victorian tours, cranberry harvests, and honey-and-garlic fairs add cozy, autumn flavor. Pack beach gear for the day and a light jacket for evenings; bring comfortable shoes for boardwalks, lighthouses, gardens, and winery lawns. If you like value, Sunday–Tuesday stays can be a steal—and booking a couple of weeks ahead still helps for popular spots.
Asbury Park – Music, Art & Off-Season Beach Vibes
Asbury Park’s retro-cool personality shines in September when the beach is mellow and the creative scene hums. Snap the classic Stone Pony photo, peek into Wonder Bar’s dog-friendly Yappy Hour, and duck into the Silverball Museum for vintage pinball. Off the boards, Cookman Avenue and Bangs Avenue deliver indie boutiques and galleries (Interwoven, Hold Fast Records, Patriae) with plenty of people-watching. For a reset, book a treatment at Kur Wellness Studio and slow things down. It’s a compact, walkable town where ocean time, culture, and great food naturally stack into one weekend.
Where to eat & drink: Taka (lively sushi), Talula’s (chewy Neapolitan-style pizza + wine), Reyla (modern Mediterranean), and Nettie’s House of Spaghetti (nearby throwback Italian). For views with your drink, Watermark’s terrace faces the ocean while Salvation Rooftop at The Asbury brings skyline-meets-sea panoramas. Pascal & Sabine is a polished brasserie for cocktails and a cheese plate.
Hotels to Stay At (Asbury Park)
A social, design-forward base with a pool, firepit, lively common spaces, and the Baronet “car-less drive-in” rooftop cinema. Easy walk to the boardwalk, Stone Pony, and Cookman Ave. You can book this hotel for as low as $295 a night in September,
Parks You Could Receive When Booking With Me
When booking this hotel with me you could receive various parks such as.
Upgrade to next room category, based upon availability at check-in
Guaranteed 1pm late check-out
Complimentary welcome drink per guest, per stay
Complimentary daily breakfast (max 2 guests)
A serene, luxe “beach house” with floor-to-ceiling glass, curated furnishings, and magical ocean views—perfect for couples who want calm steps from the sand. You can book this hotel for as low as $525 a night.
Parks You Could Receive When Booking With Me
When booking this hotel with me you could receive various parks such as.
Upgrade to next room category, based upon availability at check-in
Guaranteed 1pm late check-out
Complimentary welcome drink per guest, per stay
Complimentary daily breakfast (max 2 guests)
Cape May – Historic Charm & Seaside Relaxation
Cape May marries Victorian architecture with ocean breezes, creating an elegant backdrop for shoulder-season escapes. Stroll Washington Street Mall for local shops and sweets, then browse maker finds at West End Garage. Pair Cape May Lighthouse with Sunset Beach in one afternoon; time your visit for golden hour and watch surfers near Sunset Pavilion. Wineries like Willow Creek and Cape May Winery (plus Cape May Brewery) keep weekends lively with tastings and occasional music. With fewer crowds and softer room rates than midsummer, September is prime for a refined, relaxing fall beach trip in NJ.
Where to eat & drink: Start with farm-fresh comfort at The Blue Pig Tavern (sourced from Beach Plum Farm), then elevate dinner at 410 Bank Street (NOLA-inspired) or Sapore Italiano (refined Italian). For casual, Lucky Bones is reliable; for nightcaps, try Ugly Mug, Delaney’s, or Fin’s. Bike the promenade off-season, check tour hours, and reserve popular dining rooms ahead for weekends.
Hotels to Stay At (Cape May)
A grand, historic beachfront icon with a heated pool and multiple venues—the Brown Room for cocktails and the Boiler Room for late-night pizza and music—set on landscaped grounds steps from the ocean. You can book this hotel in September with some nights as low as $296.
Spacious one- and two-bedroom condo-style suites with resort amenities and beach-house charm—ideal for longer weekends or families who want room to spread out. You can book this hotel in September for nights as low $189.
Long Beach Island (LBI) – Relaxed Island Escape
Three miles out to sea, LBI feels like a true island getaway—wide, quieter beaches, warm water, and bayside sunsets that linger. September brings shorter waits at beloved restaurants and space to breathe on the sand; locals swear fall is as good as summer here. Mix nature and nostalgia: bird-watch at Edwin B. Forsythe National Wildlife Refuge in Holgate, then climb Barnegat Lighthouse (Old Barney) for sweeping coastal views. For rainy afternoons or pure fun, Fantasy Islandarcade packs classics and modern games. If your town permits, off-season beach driving (with a local permit) turns a beach day into a tailgate-style setup.
Where to eat & drink: The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House (late-night and lively), Delaware Ave Oyster House (cozy with creative small plates), Black Eyed Susans (excellent pizzas and apps), Black Whale (beloved salads and raw bar), and Raimondo’s (BYOB Italian for date night). Dive-bar charm lives at Baker’s Port Hole Café and Hudson House—cash is king and the jukebox still matters.
Hotels to Stay At (LBI)
Oversized suites with full kitchens, an indoor pool with a retractable roof, a rooftop for sunset cocktails, and complimentary beach gear—convenient, comfortable, and central.
Tips for Planning Your September Getaway
Book hotels and signature restaurants a couple of weeks ahead - September weekends can still sell out, especially during events. Sunday–Tuesday stays often bring better pricing and quieter streets. Verify hours for lighthouses, ferries, historic sites, wineries, and tours, since schedules shift after Labor Day. Pack for warm afternoons and crisp evenings: swimwear, breathable daywear, and light layers you can add after sunset. A small cooler, picnic blanket, and reusable water bottle make wineries, farmers’ markets, and sunset snacks easier.
Can’t-Miss Fall Events to Pair with Your Trip
Beach Haven Chowder Cook-Off – Long Beach Island, NJ (October 4–5, 2025)
Two-day chowder weekend: merchant mart Saturday, cook-off Sunday by the bay.
Cape May Victorian Weekend – Cape May, NJ (October 10–13, 2025)
House tours, trolley rides, and heritage events across America’s first seashore resort.
Chatsworth Cranberry Festival – Chatsworth, NJ (October 18–19, 2025)
A Pine Barrens harvest celebration with up to 150 craft vendors, food, and live music—rain or shine.
Final Thoughts – Make September Your New Favorite Time at the Shore
September blends summer warmth with early-fall charm, turning Asbury Park, Cape May, and LBI into easy, rewarding escapes. You’ll trade crowds for comfort, find towns energized by tastings and festivals, and enjoy warm water with cool, clear evenings. Whether you want music and murals, Victorian elegance, or island-quiet beaches, each destination shines brighter in local summer. Pick your dates, reserve your favorites, and stretch the season with fall beach trips NJ that feel full but never frantic. If you’d like a curated plan with hotel perks at select properties, I can help you book and build the perfect weekend.
Want pricing for more specific dates? Fill out this form and ill get you a free quote!
Comments